Andrew Hall / 2008 / Commodity Long

A shortage years in the making.

Andrew Hall and the slow adjustment of physical supply.

Oil Futures LongPhibro (Citigroup)Workbook estimate ↘
The story

Before the outcome was obvious.

The oil case in the workbook is built on a tension between growing demand and constrained supply. Unlike a financial position, a new source of production cannot be opened with a keystroke. That lag can allow an imbalance to persist. The model represents a multiyear commodity view with futures, ending in the 2008 oil spike. Its clean endpoint should not be mistaken for a smooth journey or a complete account of Hall’s book.

What could have gone wrong

Demand destruction, new supply, futures roll costs and leverage can overturn or erode a commodity thesis.

Understand the physical clock. Supply responses and financial holding periods rarely move at the same speed.
The numbers / interactive

Put the thesis to the test.

Change the assumptions and watch the arithmetic update. These are simplified scenarios; they do not recreate the instrument’s pricing or the path of the trade.

Model profit$1bn
Profit / stated position33.3%
Position / fund assets1.5×
How this model works

Profit ratio = profit ÷ stated position. Exposure ratio = stated position ÷ fund assets. Neither is a measure of maximum loss or a net investor return.

The workbook’s simple annualisation is profit ratio × 365 ÷ duration = 6.7%. It is linear, not compounded, and is not a repeatable annual return. Fees, financing, collateral, premium carry and changing exposures are not modelled.

Evidence & source record

What these figures mean.

Source: Legendary Trades Models, Master Comparison!A10:L10; Trade P&L Models, case 7. The following are original workbook inputs, preserved for transparency. They are estimates, not independently audited results.

Workbook position
$3bn
Workbook “gross profit”
$1bn
Workbook duration
1,825 days
Workbook fund assets
$2bn
Workbook fund return
100%
Workbook position ROI
33.3%

The fund-return field is a separate source claim, not a calculated result of this trade. Its reporting period and gross/net basis are not independently established here. Model ratios are recalculated from inputs rather than copied from rounded source ROI values.

Read the collection’s full methodology ↗

Continue exploring / Stanley DruckenmillerA new country. A new price.